What you may not know about Nancy Drew & the Hardy Boys

October 4, 1862, was the birth date of Edward Stratemeyer.  You may not be familiar with that name, but he may have had a big impact on your childhood. 

Nancy Drew, The Hardy Boys, Tom Swift, and many other kids’ series were creations of the Stratemeyer Syndicate.  Edward Stratemeyer established most of the characters and wrote story synopses.  He had contract writers turn the ideas into books.  No, there was no Carolyn Keene, no Franklin W. Dixon

By 1925, there were more than 400 different titles in various Stratemeyer series.  Over 1600 titles have now been produced.  Although Nancy Drew seems to be the most sought-after character, the others, including The Hardy Boys, Tom Swift, The Dana Girls, and Cherry Ames, and The Bobbsey Twins are all prized collectibles.  I grew up avidly reading The Hardy Boys.  The experience of reading my first one—The Mystery at Devil’s Paw (#38)—was a life-transforming event, along the lines of my first Sadie Hawkins Dance or my first bottle of Dr Pepper. 

The first Nancy Drew titles came out in 1930.  These, and all of the later Nancy Drews from the collectible era, were Grosset & Dunlap originals.  (Most Grosset & Dunlap books were reprints.)  The first three titles, in fine condition and first edition, have sold for hundreds of dollars.  How can you identify a first edition Nancy Drew?  It ain’t easy.  According to collector Helen Galvin, “There is no statement of printing on any of them, but a clue to the first edition is that the inside front flap of the dust wrapper has the title of the current volume at the bottom of the list of titles in the series.”  (Except for the first three titles, all of which list all three.) 

Nancy and Frank and Joe remain very popular among baby-boomer collectors, because often people collect books they read when they were younger.  Half Price Books gets lots of Nancy Drew and Hardy Boys books from every era, but these series books, like all other collectibles, are more valuable in earlier editions.  Condition is very important (but there is more latitude given kids’ books than other collectibles; because most were owned by children, it’s more difficult to find them in good condition).  Dust jackets appeared on the editions of the ‘30s, ‘40s and ‘50s, and the presence of a dust jacket on your Nancy Drew book can turn it from a cherished memento into a valued collector’s item.

First editions of Stratemeyer’s series titles are scarce, but the reprints through the fifties, with a dust jacket, are not so hard to come by—so keep your magnifying glasses handy and start sleuthing around!

What’s your favorite Stratemeyer series or book? — Steve


Steve is Staffing & Development Manager (aka the “Buy Guy”) at Half Price Books Corporate.

2 thoughts on “What you may not know about Nancy Drew & the Hardy Boys

  1. I have been collecting series books for nearly 40 years. I have about 700 Hardy Boys books, which includes hardcovers with dust jackets, picture covers, paperbacks, examples in 17 languages and even one in braille. That said, favorite syndicate book? Hardy Boys Mystery of Cabin Island- original text is great, revised text is pretty good too.Many don't realize that the books have been revised over the years- the first 38 Hardy Boys books and first 35 Nancy Drew books were revised starting in the late 50's and continuing into the 70's. The revisions came about because of a change in printing methods that involved remaking the printing plates. The stories were modernized, shortened and had some racial/ethnic stereotypes removed. As a result, nostalgic readers have purchased modern printings of their favorite childhood book and are disappointed to find that the story is not as they remembered it.

  2. Thanks, Dean. Yes, I have been curious about the updated, politically-corrected versions, but haven't tried reading one. I wouldn't miss the racial stereoptypes, but I might miss all the dated references to "jalopies," and other archaic terms that give the older books some nostalgic charm.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s